top of page
Search

THE 3 PARTS OF PROJECT ESTIMATION (and the 6 Best Techniques to Tackle It)

Updated: Oct 13, 2023

As a project manager (PM) you are tasked with a wide-scope of activities and, in today’s world, collaboration both internally and externally is key. But it is a PMs duty to create and align the project around its classic metrics and barriers, namely:


Scope, Time, Cost, Quality, Resources, and Risk


Understanding these well within an organization means a PM can accurately forecast a project's multiple moving parts and this is called project estimation which in-turn can provide an accurate picture or scope of work for the client. PM’s are estimating everything from the volume of work to be undertaken to who will work on the project and if budget is required.

 

This can sometimes seem unwieldy but it boils down to three major parts:


ESTIMATION OF EFFORT


You can probably glean what this is from the heading so I won’t state the obvious. What must be considered is what effort entails; are we talking time, capacity, resource availability, skill requirements? Manage and know this pool of features well and the estimation can become significantly more accurate, earlier in the project life-cycle.


ESTIMATION OF COST


Once effort is assessed, knowing the cost should be a simple equation, the answer to which is very helpful to a client.


ESTIMATION OF RESOURCE

toolkit on yellow table

Knowing the time and capacity already you can understand how much resource (human or otherwise) you’ll likely desire to provide. Knowing cost ahead of this can provide a red-flag if it seems likely that a project will be over or underserved.


These estimates can be ball-park, but should get more accurate as you progress. Having a system in place can help automate the above as well as providing a role for an accurate forecast earlier in the cycle.


ESTIMATING EFFECTIVELY AND ACCURATELY


There are multiple schools of thought on project estimation but the following six techniques are the most adopted.


Analogous/Comparative Estimating


This method aids in the reduction of ball-park estimates and given most services companies are likely to be delivering projects in a similar vein to historical ones, this technique makes a lot of sense. Essentially by starting with a completed yet similar project to the one about to be undertaken as a reference point, you simply correlate the estimates and actuals from that project and apply it to the same or similar activities about to be undertaken.


Statistical/Parametric Estimating


This method analyses the estimates required, such as time or cost, on a smaller part of the project and then multiples it up. If there are multiple deliverables the technique can be applied to each one individually. A drawback? The data feeding the metric you calculate on must be robust, as even a minor miscalculation early can result in a wide gap to accuracy in the final estimate.


Three-Point/PERT Estimating


PERT stands for Program Evaluation and Review Technique (exciting), but the essential premise is you take a best-case scenario and a worst-case scenario and average it out to provide an average “likely” outcome.


What-If Analysis


This could probably be considered the most in-depth technique as you workshop with the client (who can provide exactly the outcomes they desire) each estimate in terms of the classic metrics mentioned at the beginning of this piece, and then you conduct an impact analysis on each.


By knowing the risks that could occur and the assumptions of your client, this method can provide the most accurate forecast as each individual element has been mapped; that said it is likely to be the most time-consuming. A term to know is Work Breakdown Structure (WBS), sometimes used here as you deconstruct the project into its major units or phases. An element of good estimation overall is the ability to build-in ‘contingency’ that aids the maintenance of risk control and keep an eye on profitability, but What-if Analysis is arguably the best technique to use for this.


Bottom-up Estimation


As the name would suggest, you literally work from the bottom-up, exploring each individual element (e.g. resource) and sub-element (e.g. labor) of the project and build up the picture of what the project will eventually become. The estimate is essentially the total sum of elements created. Again a resourcing tool here can really help as you’ll want to account for all staffing overheads including holiday or illness.


Top-down Estimation


Kinda the reverse of Bottom-up. Evaluate the overarching features of the project first and then disseminate them into their component parts. This technique might also include elements of parametric estimating and/or What-if Analysis, especially WBS, as estimating in project phases is typically more accurate.

 

Not to appear contrived but I mentioned a tool or system that can aid with this. Well guess what, Precursive can aid with your project estimation, from resourcing to cost and even understanding if there’s likely risk, from capacity crunches to poor project margin. Head to our product pages to discover more or download our Playbook on getting started with Project Management on Salesforce to see how the typical five stages of a project can be enhanced with automation.

1,743 views0 comments

Find out more about the people and company. You can learn more about what makes us tick. 

 

We are passionate about changing the game for the world’s best services teams. 

 

Our mission is to help you improve time-to-value and make every customer a success story.

Asset 27.png

WHY PRECURSIVE.

About Us

Find out more about us including our mission, values and get to know the team

Salesforce Native

Give sales, services, support and customer success teams a single, shared view of the customer

Customers

Hear from customers on why they prefer Precursive to help them scale and grow their business

Professional Services Delivery

Our services team provides expertise in how the best companies improve services delivery

Support & Success Hub

Find the answer you need at our success-hub where you will find a mix of documentation, video assets and training materials

The Precursive Platform is 100% native to the Salesforce platform. Our solutions can be tailored to your needs and support a range of use cases.

 

Learn how we take the pain out of complex service delivery activities. 

 

Do the work, not the admin! 

Asset 22.png

Professional Services Automation

Increase operational efficiency with predictable services delivery and insights on performance

Project Management

Powerful project management capability designed to support high-velocity services delivery

Resource Management

Quickly mobilize your project teams, manage demand and avoid capacity crunches